Jason Castro
I Just Want to Be Your Everything
Hauling out the guitar for a second week in a row, the Rastifar-Idol impresses with his ability to arrange an ancient song into something vaguely contemporary-sounding. Unfortunately, he ain't much of a singer. Following in the vocal tracks of Andy Gibb could make anyone sound weak voiced, but Castro wasn't doing the high parts and squeak takes—he was well within his normal range. Still, Randy "loves the dreds," and I'm guessing America will enough to keep him around for another week, too.